School closures leave lost generation in south-east Asia

His family doesn’t own a smart phone and didn’t know how to help him study at home.

Instead, he has been working as a labourer drying fish and, pleased to have the additional money while his school wasn’t open, his parents have no plans for him to go back.

While nearly half a million schools across Indonesia have finally been permitted to reopen in a alternation form in the past month as infection numbers have eased, there are many children like Dini and Yanto who haven’t returned.

Students wearing confront masks as an elementary school in Jakarta, Indonesia re-opens in late August.Credit:AP

In North Sumatra, the head of the provincial education office said last week about 800 students hadn’t gone back to school because they were lazy, they had to work or because they were now married.

It is an upsetting trend reflected across the archipelago and around south-east Asia, where schools have been closed for as long as 18 months.

A study of 112,000 poor families by the United Nations children’s agency (UNICEF) in Indonesia discloses 12,000 of their children had left school already before the global health crisis and three out of four who remained studying had at the minimum one risk factor for dropping out.

They include having to work, which 53 per cent of the children now had to do as parents lost jobs during the pandemic, in addition as caring for siblings, having a disability and child marriage.

The virus is nevertheless a real threat in Indonesia, with less than 20 per cent of its 270 million people fully vaccinated, but Indonesian Education Minister Nadien Makarim is more concerned about “the long-lasting impact of distance learning” than children catching COVID-19 at school.

“Research from various institutions shows how scary learning loss is,” he said.

“I’m more worried that only 40 per cent of schools do offline [in-person] classes, so there are 60 per cent of schools who are truly allowed to do offline classes but they do not do it,” he said.

Children’s advocates also highlight the drawbacks of home learning on the nutrition of children, particularly those from disadvantaged areas, and of the consequences of missing the socialisation of school.

“[Young] children learn from mimicking and absorbing direct experiences,” said Alexandra Silitonga, an Indonesian education expert.

“If the educators cannot translate the direct experiences into virtual learning, it is deeply felt. In the early days of the pandemic, during the change [to online learning] we saw that the children of these groups of ages struggled the most. How do you expect a three-year old kid to learn from speed?”

In the Philippines, where confront-to-confront tuition has been on keep up since schools closed their doors in March 2020, UNICEF education specialist Tess Felipe warns the “mental and psycho-social effect is going to be tremendous”.

President Rodrigo Duterte has been urged to green light a pilot program to shift the country’s 26.3 million school students back into classrooms.

Syaiful, 12, who can’t freely move his lower body or right hand, studies at home with his mother Nurhidayah in Banyumas, Central Java.

Syaiful, 12, who can’t freely move his lower body or right hand, studies at home with his mother Nurhidayah in Banyumas, Central Java.Credit:UNICEF

But as the Philippines grapples with a new COVID case spike, another school year began remotely on September 13, with enrolment numbers down 2 per cent on pre-pandemic figures.

A further surge of secondary school drop-outs is expected this school year, particularly in Muslim-majority Bangsamoro on Mindanao, the poorest vicinity of the country, according to a recent report on the effect of COVID-19 on child poverty in the Philippines.

“There [have been] drop-outs and many were related to the difficulties of the lessons … the children gave up because they don’t want to have difficulties and parents have challenges on helping,” Felipe said.

“And for some of the older kids in senior high school, aged maybe 17 or 18, they have to help earning money so that the family can survive.”

Students attend a socially distanced class at a high school in Phnom Penh as schools began re-opening in Cambodia last month.Credit:Getty Images

With south-east Asia’s largest nations facing monumental responsibilities to vaccinate their populations, UNICEF is trying to raise funds for jabs with its “Give the World a Shot” campaign.

But already in countries where vaccine access has been easier to come by, there are problems.
Quality of education shapes as another weakening factor in Cambodia because of a decision by the Hun Sen government not to recruit new teachers in the next year and instead direct resources towards fighting the virus.

Cambodia has not been crushed as badly as Indonesia and the Philippines by COVID-19 but a seven-month freeze in physical schooling will have long-lasting ramifications, according to ChildFund country director Prashant Verma.

Schools began re-opening in Phnom Penh and beyond in September but Prashant fears 10 to 12 per cent of children won’t go back because only half of all students had access to online lessons.


“There was such great momentum produced in the past four or five years with education reform in Cambodia,” he said.

“But this whole seven-month gap has literally shut down everything.

“It will take some time to re-energise and re-organise the whole course of action of helping teachers, parents and young children to come back to school.

“And if a second or third wave [of the virus] comes, God knows what’s going to happen. It will put us in very bad shape.“

* Children’s names have been changed

– with Karuni Rompies

Click: See details

Leave a Reply